NEWS & INFORMATION

× Close 800.638.6012

10 KPIs Every Construction Fleet Manager Should Track

 Having the right data lets you make the important decisions necessary to reduce your costs and improve the productivity of your construction fleet. But what is the right data? There is an almost infinite selection of key performance indicators (KPIs) you can track, but if you track too many of them, it can become impossible to sift them into meaningful information to guide decisions. And if you choose the wrong ones, you might end up making decisions based on bad data. 

Here’s a list of 10 straightforward KPIs that will help you keep your construction fleet lean, effective, and profitable.  

Unscheduled Downtime 

One of the biggest KPIs to track is how much unscheduled downtime you have in your fleet. Unscheduled downtime is time when your vehicles aren’t able to be used, and when they’re eating up your precious resources: limited shop time if you do your own maintenance, or money if someone else performs your construction fleet service. Of course, you don’t always have the option of doing your own maintenance if your truck experiences a breakdown—you might need a tow or roadside service to get your vehicle running again.  

In addition to maintenance costs, unscheduled downtime can cost you in work stoppage and delays. Sometimes, you might have to rent replacement equipment to meet contractual obligations, and that adds up, too.  

Industry estimates say that the average fleet has about 25% unscheduled downtime. However, the best fleets can keep this number much lower, as little as 5%

 unscheduled downtime. In addition to unscheduled downtime on a fleet basis, keep track of it for individual vehicles. That can help you identify problematic equipment so you can consider replacement. 

Percentage of Preventive Maintenance Hours 

Preventive maintenance is the way you avoid having too much unscheduled downtime. If you’re having more unscheduled downtime than you want, it could be due to many things, but one of the most obvious is that you’re not spending enough time on preventive maintenance.  

Ideally, most of your shop time should be preventive maintenance. If you’re spending most of your time on repairs, it could mean several things: 

  • You aren’t spending enough time on preventive maintenance 
  • Your maintenance plan is not effective 
  • You have unreliable equipment in need of replacement 

Some of these other KPIs will help you understand which is likely the case.  

Mean Time to Repair (MTTR) 

A sign that the problem might be in your shop is you have a long mean time to repair (MTTR). If your shop isn’t able to get to and complete work orders in a timely fashion, it extends the length of unscheduled downtime and prevents vehicles from getting the preventive maintenance they need.  

When your MTTR is high, you should consider several solutions. One is to increase your available shop hours. You might do this by adding more mechanics, by authorizing more overtime, or by removing other responsibilities that are currently taking up your mechanics’ time.   

These can create other potential costs, so you need to weigh these decisions against other solutions, such as replacing problematic equipment.  

Percentage of Maintenance Overtime Hours 

 

Having too many overtime hours is an inefficient way to operate your shop long-term. Overtime is expensive, especially since the mechanics you’re going to be counting on most often are those with the most seniority, and, therefore, likely  the highest salaries. In addition, constant overtime can make employees inefficient due to exhaustion and disgruntled because they are spending too much time at work.  

As a general rule, if your overtime hours equal more than 25 hours a week, you would be well-served in adding another mechanic. If you decide to get your MTTR down by authorizing more overtime hours, you should monitor this closely.  

Repeat Repair Rate 

Your repeat repair rate is an important metric of how well your shop is working. Ideally, when something gets fixed, it should stay fixed. However, that’s not always the case, and some components tend to break down repeatedly.  

With a high repeat repair rate, consider a few possibilities. If the repeat repair rate is on multiple vehicles and components, the problem is likely in your shop somewhere. Consider scheduling some additional training to make sure your personnel have the skills they need to perform the repairs. However, if the problem is limited to either a single make, model, or even vehicle, the problem is likely defective equipment. Use the repeat repair costs to help you decide when is the right time to replace the problematic machines.  

Maintenance Costs as a Percentage of Estimated Replacement Value 

As vehicles age or get worn out, their maintenance costs tend to rise. At a certain point, they become too expensive to run, and then it makes more sense to replace the vehicle than to keep maintaining it.  

As a general rule, once maintenance costs reach 5-10% of the replacement cost, it’s time to think about replacement. However, the specific time to replace a fleet vehicle depends on the vehicle, the availability of replacements, and your company’s capital expenses plan.  

Maintenance Cost Per Engine hour 

Another metric to look at when deciding whether to replace a piece of equipment is the maintenance cost per engine hour. Maintenance cost per engine hour can be high because either a piece of equipment needs a lot of maintenance or else it doesn’t get utilized very much.  

Once your maintenance cost per engine hour approaches the hourly rental rate for a piece of equipment, it might make more sense to rent a piece of equipment rather than own it.  

Equipment Utilization Rate 

Checking equipment utilization rate is another way to decide whether it makes sense to own a piece of equipment or if you are better off renting. If a certain piece of equipment is spending most of its time unused in your yard, then it might make sense to sell the equipment and rent a replacement when you need it. Check availability of the equipment before you make this decision. If the equipment is so specialized that it isn’t available for rent in the area, it might make sense to hold on to it to make sure you have it when you need it.  

Driver Accident Rates 

It’s unfair to blame the equipment when unplanned downtime, repeat repairs, and other high maintenance costs are due to operator error. To ma

ke sure you’re properly attributing costs, keep track of driver accident rates as well as equipment problems. If you have one or more drivers with high accident rates, take steps to bring those down, either by talking to the operators, ordering more training, or replacing the operators.  

Total Cost of Ownership 

Tracking total cost of ownership is critical to ensuring you are making smart replacement decisions for your fleet. If certain makes or models of machines have a much higher total cost of ownership than others, you should not replace like with like—consider whether there might be more reliable replacement options.  

Let McClung Equip Your Construction Fleet 

At McClung-Logan, we’ve been the leading construction equipment dealer in the Mid-Atlantic region since 1939. We’ve maintained that position by providing our clients with honest, informed advice about heavy equipment decisions. We tailor our recommendations to your business’ specific needs. McClung-Logan can do that because we take the time to get to know you and your business. We believe that long-term relationships built on the success of your business are best for everyone evolved.  

We are able to supply your specific equipment needs with like-for-like replacements or with higher-performing alternatives based on your metrics and needs. That includes all the leading brands: 

  • Volvo 
  • Takeuchi 
  • Mecalac 
  • Avant 
  • K-Tec 
  • Prinoth 
  • Gradall 
  • Shuttlewagon 
  • Dura-A-Lift 

We can supply both new and used construction equipment. 

We are also prepared to supply your parts needs for these and other types of construction equipment.  

Contact one of our branch locations today to speak with a Territory Manager. McClung-Logan is a full-service heavy equipment dealer serving the Mid-Atlantic region. 

Construction Fleet KPIs: Frequently Asked Questions 

What KPIs should a construction fleet manager track? 

Construction fleet managers should track 10 core KPIs: unscheduled downtime, percentage of preventive maintenance hours, mean time to repair (MTTR), percentage of maintenance overtime hours, repeat repair rate, maintenance costs as a percentage of replacement value, maintenance cost per engine hour, equipment utilization rate, driver accident rates, and total cost of ownership. Together, these metrics help reduce costs, improve productivity, and guide repair, replacement, and rental decisions without overwhelming managers with too much data. 

What is a good unscheduled downtime rate for a construction fleet? 

The average construction fleet has about 25% unscheduled downtime, while top-performing fleets keep it as low as 5%. Unscheduled downtime costs money through repair expenses, towing or roadside service, work stoppages, project delays, and rental equipment needed to meet contractual obligations. Tracking downtime for each vehicle, not just the whole fleet, helps identify problem equipment that may need replacement. 

How does preventive maintenance affect fleet downtime? 

Preventive maintenance is the primary way to reduce unscheduled downtime, and most shop time should go to preventive work rather than repairs. If a shop spends most of its time on repairs, it usually means one of three things: too little time is spent on preventive maintenance, the maintenance plan is ineffective, or the fleet has unreliable equipment that needs replacing. 

What does a high mean time to repair (MTTR) indicate? 

A high mean time to repair (MTTR) usually means the maintenance shop cannot complete work orders quickly enough. This extends unscheduled downtime and delays preventive maintenance. Common fixes include adding mechanics, authorizing overtime, or removing non-maintenance duties from mechanics, though each option should be weighed against alternatives such as replacing problematic equipment. 

How much maintenance overtime is too much? 

As a general rule, if maintenance overtime exceeds 25 hours per week, adding another mechanic is usually more cost-effective. Sustained overtime is expensive because it often falls on senior, higher-paid mechanics, and it can reduce efficiency and morale through fatigue. 

What causes a high repeat repair rate? 

A high repeat repair rate points to either shop performance issues or defective equipment. If repeat repairs occur across many vehicles and components, the problem is likely in the shop, and additional technician training may help. If repeat repairs are concentrated on a single make, model, or machine, the equipment itself is likely the problem, and repeat repair costs can help determine when to replace it. 

When should construction equipment be replaced? 

Construction equipment should be considered for replacement once annual maintenance costs reach 5–10% of its replacement cost. The exact timing also depends on the type of equipment, the availability of replacements, and the company’s capital expense plan. Total cost of ownership and repeat repair costs are also useful inputs for replacement decisions. 

When is it better to rent construction equipment instead of owning it? 

Renting often makes more sense than owning when a machine’s maintenance cost per engine hour approaches its hourly rental rate, or when the machine sits unused most of the time. Low utilization drives up per-hour costs, so selling idle equipment and renting as needed can save money. The exception is highly specialized equipment that is not available for rent locally, which may be worth keeping on hand. 

Why should fleet managers track driver accident rates? 

Tracking driver accident rates ensures that downtime, repeat repairs, and high maintenance costs are correctly attributed to operator error rather than equipment problems. When specific operators have high accident rates, managers can address it through coaching, additional training, or reassignment. 

Why is total cost of ownership important for fleet replacement decisions? 

Total cost of ownership (TCO) shows which makes and models are truly the most economical over their service life. If certain machines have a much higher TCO than others, fleet managers should avoid replacing like with like and instead consider more reliable alternatives. 

Where can Mid-Atlantic contractors get construction equipment and parts? 

McClung-Logan has been a leading construction equipment dealer in the Mid-Atlantic region since 1939, offering new and used equipment, parts, and service. The dealer carries brands including Volvo, Takeuchi, Mecalac, Avant, K-Tec, Prinoth, Gradall, Shuttlewagon, and Dura-A-Lift, and can recommend like-for-like replacements or higher-performing alternatives based on a fleet’s KPIs. Contractors can contact a local branch to speak with a Territory Manager. 

Speak with an equipment expert today!

Call or message us today.